8 Comments
User's avatar
SG's avatar

Thank you for this delineation on how the hell this happened. UVA was so fortunate to get Jim Ryan at a time it faced tough challenges, including the pandemic.

The retaliation against Ryan was illegal, just like the DOJ extortion attempts against “DEI” and the threats to rescind federal research contracts on cancer research etc.

As you said DEI, is NOT illegal but discrimination on the basis of race, religion, sex, IS illegal. As are policies of inequity in pay and the exclusion of people with disabilities etc in employment and admissions considerations.

This is utter madness. It is not. “ politics”; it is ABUSE Of POWER.

I’m so mad. Youngkin has turned out to be not just petty with his faux attacks on critical race theory but a real danger to the commonwealth and the integrity of its higher education system .

He needs to hear from all of us. Glad Yom Scully spoke up. Only Republicans can make this madness stop. Just like it took republicans to force Nixon to resign. Why are they all so afraid of trump?? They know he’s a danger to the Country and the free world.

SMH.

Expand full comment
SG's avatar

Forgive the typo. Glad Tom Scully spoke out. Wish W would speak out too. Especially about the illegal kidnappings (“detained” is a euphemism when masked men are disappearing people. ) the failures to provide due process is making us look like a third world country under an autocratic ruler. and treating people seeking asylum , including minors, as if they are violent criminals, imprisoning them and using our tax dollars to shop to maximum security prison in El Salvador is beyond horrifying and indistinguishable from Hitler’s tactics and scapegoating.

Expand full comment
Erik Midelfort's avatar

Thank you, David Toscano,

You make it clear that the fight is not just over one president of one university, but over an assault on higher education and intellectual freedom more generally. It’s not clear what action might be effective aside from voting in coming elections.

Expand full comment
Erik Midelfort's avatar

Thank you, David Toscano,

You make it clear that the fight is not just over one president of one university, but over an assault on higher education and intellectual freedom more generally. It’s not clear what action might be effective aside from voting in coming elections.

Expand full comment
Reese Erwin's avatar

This is a beautiful article defending intellectual freedom and UVA attacks by Trump’s DOJ and Gov. Youngkin. Let’s share it widely.

Together, Trump and Youngkin are dismantling public education as fascist dictators do. (Don’t let Youngkin’s mild demeanor and “nice-guy” facade deceive you.)They are definitely following the playbooks of Orban, Putin, Erdogan, Stalin, Hitler, and Mussolini. We need to be very alarmed and commit to resisting while we can and however we can. These are serious and dangerous maneuvers.

Expand full comment
Jerry Ray's avatar

Thank you for speaking up for our university against the assault by federal and state republicans trying to undermine the principles on which this university was founded. This, along with the assault on our nation’s democratic institutions, is creating a tyranny of small decisions that in total supports an authoritarian agenda. UVa needs to stand firm against this federal takeover of UVa’s president.

Expand full comment
jeffrey snyder's avatar

Knowing the when, where, why and how of their coming, should we not be able to stop them in their tracks?

If not, why not?

Are we stuck on Hamlet's spot, or perhaps playing a longer game? ... or covet that power?

Expand full comment
Beatriz Lopes's avatar

Thank you Mr. Toscano for continuing fighting for freedom, human rights and democracy in VA and USA.

Expand full comment